Confidence in Grocery Stores and Government Declines Sharply, dunnhumby Study Finds

The pandemic’s effects continue to alter consumers’ shopping behavior, who are losing confidence in grocery stores’ handling of COVID-19.

Data science company dunnhumby revealed the findings in its 18-month global study of the impact of COVID-19 on customer attitudes and behavior in 24 countries. 

The eighth wave of the dunnhumby Consumer Pulse Survey found that 64% of U.S. consumers reported that grocery stores are not doing a good job with COVID-19, compared to February 2021, when 50% of respondents reported grocers were doing a good job. 

In addition, 83% reported that the government isn’t doing a good job either, marking the lowest point of confidence in the government’s handling of the crisis and the second-lowest globally.

Consumers’ concerns with grocery stores span from worries that things are not returning to normal (76%), unvaccinated shoppers in the stores (34%), and still extremely worried about the virus (26%). 

Related Article: U.S. Grocery Consumers Increasingly Worried About Rising Food Prices

Although 21% said no store provides good value for the money, Walmart continues to be cited as providing the best value (29%), with Aldi (12%), Kroger (7%), and Target (6%) following respectively. 

Amazon fell out of the top five stores for value and landed with 4%, said dunnhumby.

“After living with the pandemic for 20 months, consumers are now twice as concerned about their finances as they are about Covid itself. With inflation persisting and government stimulus’ phased out, the majority of shoppers are now looking for greater value,” said Grant Steadman, president for North America at dunnhumby. “Retailers who are perceived as offering more value, and respond to their customers increasing need for this, will earn the loyalty of the new customers they gained during the early phases of the pandemic.”

Key Findings From the dunnhumby Study:

  • Shopping trips and restaurant patronage is returning to pre-pandemic behavior. During the 18-month study, consumers have changed how often they shopped from a low of just 3.8 trips a week in March 2020, to 5.6 trips a week in July 2020, to six trips a week in September 2021. Similarly, over the same period, visits to restaurants for carryout, delivery or eat-in have ranged from a March 2020 low of 62% of consumers, to 78% in July 2020, and 82% in September 2021, the highest amount since the start of the study. The number of consumers eating in a restaurant has also increased from just 10% in March 2020 to 49% in September 2021, also the highest point in the study.
  • While consumers’ outlook on the economy has improved, 55% still feel the economy is weak, and 40% report that their personal finances are also weak. Over the eight waves, consumers’ perception of the state of the economy has improved by 20 percentage points compared to just a 5point improvement in how they feel about their own personal finances. Globally, Brazil (75%), Thailand (69%), and France (63%) are at the bottom with their consumers reporting their personal finances are weak.
  • Levels of worry about COVID-19 in the U.S. have continued to drop and is at its lowest level (17%), a 14-point drop since March 2020. The U.S. is in the lower half of countries surveyed on the dunnhumby Worry Index with Brazil (39%), Malaysia (38%), Chile (38%), Thailand (35%), Portugal (35%), Mexico (33%), and Japan (31%) in the top half of countries reporting higher levels of worry.
  • Value-seeking consumers (66%) continue to surpass quality seeking consumers (19%), although value seekers’ numbers declined slightly (5 points) since the last wave. The two most common behaviors are shopping at stores with the lowest prices (55%) and shopping at stores with the best quality (44%). Next are stocking up when things go on sale (36%) and paying more for quality (30%).
  • The number of people who shop both store and online has increased to 47% since the beginning of the pandemic when it was at 35%. The U.S. is in the middle of countries in the number of omni-channel shoppers, with China leading all at 97% and Hungary trailing at 19%. Satisfaction in the U.S. with online shopping is now identical to that for in-store shopping 32%.
  • Cash remains king as the dominant payment method (49%), followed by traditional credit cards (46%), debit cards (41%), with mobile apps trailing (13%).
  • Just 14% of U.S. survey respondents are concerned with data privacy. Only in China and Thailand do more than 20% of consumers seem concerned.